Kyle, interesting... I knew that is not possible. Do you have a lot of high quality backlinks left or did you start building new ones?
How to Get More Clicks with Low Rankings
6/8/2012 The ultimate goal for getting top rankings is not the rankings themselves, but actually getting more qualified traffic and from that, more sales, leads, subscriptions or whatever your macro conversion is...it’s not the higher organic position that gets the highest click share in SERPs. Not always, at least.